Can debt collectors collect more than you owe?
Isabella Turner
Updated on February 18, 2026
A debt collector cannot collect more money than what is owed. Occasionally, a debt collector is permitted to collect interest on a debt, but only when that interest was expressly authorized by the original agreement creating the debt, or permitted by law.
Can you pay a collection agency to remove from credit report?
Under a pay for delete agreement, debt collectors take the collections account off your credit report in exchange for payment on the debt. The collections account will be deleted, but negative information about late payments to the original creditor will persist.
Can a collection agency charge more than the original debt?
A collection agency may add additional interest and fees to the balance as part of their collection efforts, so the collection amount may be greater than the original amount that was written off by your creditor.
Can a collection agency legally put their account on my credit report?
Once a debt is sold to a collection agency, they can begin reporting that account to the credit reporting agencies. The collection agency becomes the legal owner of the debt and has the right to begin collection efforts. Once reported, both the original account and the collection account will appear on a credit report.
When do you have multiple collections on your credit report?
A “double jeopardy” credit report is when you have multiple collections for the same account on your credit report. This can happen when the debt is being reported by both the original creditor and the collection agency on your credit report or when the debt is sold to another collection agency.
Can a collection debt be removed from your credit report?
As a result, you could, for example, be fortunate enough to get one of two collection debts removed from your credit report, yet see no score improvement if the remaining collection is the more recent of the two. 4. Does the Amount of the Collection Debt Matter?